We've bantered and battled about the costs and effectiveness of using tablets in the classroom -- focusing mostly on the use of tablets in colleges and elementary schools. We haven't talked much about using them in high schools, however. Luckily, I've now gotten some insight from someone who's actually starting to deploy tablets in a high school setting.
Damian Baraty is technology integration specialist at Fountain Valley School (FVS) -- a private boarding school for grades 9 through 12 -- in Colorado Springs, Colo. At the beginning of this school year, FVS began deploying Barnes & Noble Nooks on a trial basis.
(Of course it must be said that Fountain Valley School's budget, operations, and spending will be rather different from public high schools. It's also worth noting that all Nooks are far cheaper than iPad 2s. The bare bones e-reader, the Nook Simple Touch, is $99. As for the tablets, the Nook Color tablet costs $199 and the Nook Tablet -- which has more battery life and twice the storage of a Nook Color -- is $249, which is half the price of an iPad 2.)
FVS is testing out the Nooks as e-readers and tablets in three classes: junior-level English, freshmen physics, and the Advanced Placement computer science course that Baraty himself teaches.
"The results are mixed," he said. "It was easiest to find books for the English class. The [digital rights management] on science and computer science books make it a little more difficult to employ Nooks regularly in those classes. It seems it will take publishers a few more years to get the balance of DRM and usability right to make using a tablet solution possible."
Although the science and tech classes' use of Nooks as e-readers is limited by publishers of those e-textbooks, the teachers of these classes have found plenty of other exciting ways to use the tablets. To squeeze as much classroom richness out of the tablets as possible, Baraty has been able to root some of the Nooks (which use the Android OS).
"Rooting makes Barnes & Noble nervous, and may make it impossible to manage the devices through them," said Baraty, "but I teach computer science, and my students were using rooted Nooks to program robots, control them remotely, and bring up richer content and load apps that would not be possible on the stock. Our physics teachers like to use Flash-based animations and simulations."
The last time I wrote about tablets in schools, you smart E2 readers and I started discussing whether or not using e-textbooks for math and science classes (specifically those developed for iPads) was cost-effective for college students or high school administrators. We discussed the pros and cons of letting students purchase the tablets from the school. Baraty has thought of that too.
"Students will return the Nooks at the end of the year," he said. "If we continue the trial, we can see cycling the Nook after two years and letting students keep them after that time, having broken even on the cost of books."
I told Baraty he was a trailblazer. "Maybe not quite a trailblazer," he said. "Perhaps a bulldozer."
@angelfuego I've had the same experience. I used to spend hours and hours drinking coffee, reading, studying, writing at a Barnes & Noble or Borders coffee shop. Just a few weeks ago I asked my father to meet me at the one beside Madison Square Garden... I didn't notice it had gone out of business!
It's worth noting... Barnes&Noble is doing better than Borders... how much of that success/survival should be credited to the Nook?
@angelfuego Interesting that you should bring up cursive writing. Pablo Valerio wrote a post here about"The Importance of Cursive Writing," a few months ago. The E2 community had a lot to say about it! Check it out: http://www.enterpriseefficiency.com/author.asp?section_id=1077&doc_id=236382
@Rowan I think you've just given some graduate student a perfect idea for a thesis project: "I wonder what kind of equation could be used to determine how many books are equivalently damaging to an e-reader...."
I would love to see more political involvement in our public education system, not just lip service. So many smart, innovative people in this country. We could overhaul the whole education system if there was more political will. A lot of other countries considered less advanced technologically than we are give education more serious consideration than we do and get better results, at least on tests.
@bnazarian - The biggest hurdle to this all is the transitional infrastructure to move in this direction. We might even see some political involvement in this arena (if there isn't already) as an effort for going 'green'.
I agree, definitely tablets are going to take over textbooks in classrooms from K-12 to university. Right now though, it's just starting to make sense for school districts. If I were a technology director in a district, I'd hold off on a larger scale deployment. But if a district can afford it with, particularly if there are sufficient private investments to the district, introduce tablets on a limited basis. They should definitely go for it. Tablets/pads are good tool that's going to get better. It surprises me it's taking as long as it is to come up with really good tablet solutions for highschool and university level students. I mean this is a huge market.
The thing I am afraid of getting too digital in schools is that there is a risk of kid's devising & solution finding power/skills may go undermine. It's much easier to copy the homework on a tablet from someone instead of doing your own, or searching a solution on a google instead of workout yourself.
The blogs and comments posted on EnterpriseEfficiency.com do not reflect the views of TechWeb, EnterpriseEfficiency.com, or its sponsors. EnterpriseEfficiency.com, TechWeb, and its sponsors do not assume responsibility for any comments, claims, or opinions made by authors and bloggers. They are no substitute for your own research and should not be relied upon for trading or any other purpose.